Why Your Florida Personal Injury Lawyer Won't Help You with your Car Damage Claim, And Why We Do
Property damage claims in Florida follow different rules than personal injury cases, and surprisingly, most Florida property damage lawyer services operate separately from personal injury representation. In Florida, you may seek property damage compensation in four different scenarios, depending on who's at fault and what insurance coverage is available.
Despite searching for "property damage lawyers near me," you might discover that many attorneys aren't eager to handle your case. This reluctance increased significantly after Florida's 2023 tort reforms eliminated attorney fee recovery for property damage claims. Many Fort Myers Auto Accident Lawyers only want to represent you on your injury claim and let you handle your car damage claim on your own.
At Pittman Law Firm, P.L. we understand how difficult and confusing it can be to be expected to handle the damage claim for your vehicle by yourself. We feel that assisting our clients with their injury claims and helping them resolve their car damage claim at no additional cost is a critical part of fully representing our clients and providing the best service that we can.
Why Property Damage and Personal Injury Are Handled Separately
After a car accident in Fort Myers, understanding why property damage and personal injury claims follow separate paths is crucial for maximizing your compensation. These claims differ fundamentally in several key areas.Different types of compensation involved
Personal injury and property damage claims cover entirely different losses. Personal injury claims encompass medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, and other damages related to physical harm. In contrast, property damage claims typically focus on the repair cost or the damaged property's fair market value.
For vehicle damage, insurance companies must pay not only for necessary repairs but also for towing, storage, and loss of use. Furthermore, if your vehicle is repaired rather than totaled, you may be entitled to compensation for its diminished value—the reduction in your car's market price resulting from accident history. This diminished value occurs because accidents often appear on Carfax reports, negatively impacting future resale value.
Separate insurance processes and policies
Insurance companies maintain distinct processes for handling these two claim types. A property damage claim and a personal injury claim are separate matters, each handled differently under the law. Even when the same adjuster manages both claims, they maintain separate claim numbers and reserve funds.
Property damage claims tend to be straightforward because the evidence is clear. Consequently, many people handle these claims directly with insurance companies without legal assistance. Personal injury claims, meanwhile, require extensive documentation including medical records, wage verification, and expert testimony.
When settling, you can resolve your property damage claim quickly while keeping your injury claim open—provided your settlement documents clearly state "property damage only".
How Florida law treats each claim type
Florida law establishes different frameworks for each claim type. Personal Injury Protection (PIP) provides $10,000 in medical and disability benefits plus $5,000 in death benefits for injuries from motor vehicle accidents.
For property damage liability, Florida requires minimum coverage of $10,000. Insurers cannot force you to purchase property damage liability coverage exceeding this amount as a condition for providing PIP benefits.
Most notably, these claims operate under separate timelines. While property damage claims typically resolve within days or weeks, personal injury claims often take months or even years to settle properly, especially when treatment is ongoing or permanent injuries are involved.
When seeking assistance from a florida property damage lawyer, understand that many attorneys focus exclusively on either property damage or personal injury cases due to these fundamental differences.
Why Personal Injury Lawyers Avoid Property Damage Claims
Looking for a Florida property damage lawyer can prove frustrating for many Fort Myers car accident victims. Personal injury attorneys typically decline to handle standalone property damage claims even if they are presenting their clients for their injury claims.
However, we at Pittman Law Firm, P.L. offer our clients help with their car damage claims at no cost to them when representing them for injuries sustained in a car accident.
2023 Florida tort reform and fee limitations
Recent sweeping changes to Florida law have dramatically altered the legal landscape for property damage claims. Most importantly, the 2023 tort reform eliminated one-way attorney's fees for plaintiffs in first-party cases. For over a century, Florida law entitled property owners to collect attorney fees from insurance companies when successfully challenging claim denials or underpayments. Under the new legislation, even if you win your lawsuit against an insurer, you're no longer entitled to any attorney fees.
This legal shift creates a troubling scenario: insurance companies now have little incentive to promptly pay claims. Since the worst-case scenario for insurers is paying only the original amount owed—even after losing a lawsuit—they benefit from delaying payments and investing that money elsewhere.
Lack of financial incentive for attorneys
Personal injury attorneys operate on a contingency fee basis, meaning they only get paid a percentage of what they recover for you. With property damage claims typically involving smaller amounts, the potential compensation rarely justifies the time investment.
Property damage claims are often straightforward
Generally, property damage claims follow a relatively clear-cut process compared to injury cases. The evidence is typically visible and quantifiable, making these claims more suitable for direct negotiation with insurance companies.
Moreover, since Florida reduced the statute of limitations for negligence claims from four years to two years, attorneys must prioritize time-sensitive cases. Thus, when searching "property damage lawyers near me," understand that most firms focus on cases offering sufficient compensation to offset their time and expertise.
What to Do If You Only Have a Property Damage Claim
Handling a standalone property damage claim requires systematic steps to maximize your compensation. Following the right approach can often resolve your issue without extensive legal assistance.
Filing a claim with your insurance company
Initially, contact your insurance provider promptly after the damage occurs. Your insurer will assign an adjuster and provide a claim number. For vehicle damage, you can file through your own insurance (subject to deductibles) or the at-fault party's insurance. Emergency repairs should only be undertaken after documenting the damage—save all receipts for reimbursement.
How to document your property damage properly
Proper documentation forms the backbone of successful claims. Take wide-angle photos of entire rooms alongside close-ups of specific damage. Create a detailed inventory listing each damaged item, including brand names, models, purchase dates, and estimated values. Store receipts, warranty information, and repair estimates in digital format for easy access.
Using 'property damage lawyers near me' to find help
Although rare for standalone claims, legal representation becomes necessary if your insurer denies coverage, undervalues damage, or engages in bad faith practices. Before meeting with a Florida property damage lawyer, gather relevant documentation—photos, insurance policies, repair estimates, and correspondence.
When a Lawyer Might Still Help With Property Damage
Even after Florida's tort reforms, certain situations still warrant seeking legal representation for property damage claims.
If your claim is denied or undervalued
Accordingly, you should consider consulting a florida property damage lawyer whenever your insurer disputes your claim or offers significantly less than required for repairs. Attorneys can challenge denials by highlighting relevant policy provisions and gathering supplemental evidence. Furthermore, if your property damage is substantial or involves complex liability issues, professional legal assistance becomes increasingly valuable.
When property damage is tied to a personal injury case
Property damage claims often accompany personal injury cases. Underneath these circumstances, attorneys document both property damage evidence and injury costs in a comprehensive demand package. Thereafter, they negotiate separate settlements for medical expenses and property damage. Approximately 95% of combined claims resolve through settlement rather than litigation.
Bad faith insurance practices and legal remedies
Insurance companies sometimes employ questionable tactics—unjustified denials, unreasonable delays, or deliberate undervaluation—constituting bad faith. Recognizable warning signs include lack of communication, lowball offers, improper investigations, and confusing policy explanations. Should your insurer act in bad faith, property damage lawyers near me can pursue legal remedies including compensatory damages for wrongfully denied claims. In particularly egregious cases, punitive damages may be available to discourage future misconduct.
Conclusion
Navigating Florida's property damage claims system presents unique challenges compared to personal injury cases. Unlike personal injury attorneys who work on contingency, most lawyers avoid standalone property damage cases due to the 2023 tort reform eliminating attorney fee recovery. Therefore, understanding your options becomes essential when facing property damage issues.
Although personal injury and property damage often result from the same incident, these claims follow entirely different paths. Your property damage claim focuses on repair costs and diminished value, while personal injury claims cover medical expenses and pain suffering. Additionally, insurance companies handle these claims through separate processes, even assigning different claim numbers.
Most property damage claims resolve directly between claimants and insurance companies without legal intervention. However, certain situations still warrant professional assistance. Consider consulting a property damage lawyer if your insurer denies coverage, undervalues your claim, or engages in bad faith practices. Similarly, substantial damages or complex liability issues might justify legal representation despite the changed fee structure.
The landscape for property damage claims in Florida has undeniably changed. Yet armed with proper documentation, reasonable expectations, and knowledge of when to seek professional help, you can still effectively navigate the system and secure fair compensation for your property damage.
Key Takeaways
Understanding why personal injury lawyers avoid property damage claims can save you time and help you pursue the right legal strategy for your Florida case.
• Florida's 2023 tort reform eliminated attorney fee recovery for property damage claims, making these cases financially unattractive to personal injury lawyers who work on contingency.
• Property damage and personal injury claims follow separate legal processes with different compensation types, insurance procedures, and timelines—you have four years for property damage versus two for personal injury.
• Most standalone property damage claims can be resolved directly with insurance companies through proper documentation, photos, and detailed inventories without legal representation.
• Property damage claims tied to personal injury cases still warrant legal representation since attorneys can negotiate comprehensive settlements covering both types of damages.
While the legal landscape has shifted against property damage claimants, understanding these distinctions empowers you to choose the most effective approach for your specific situation and maximize your compensation potential.
FAQs
Q1. Why don't personal injury lawyers typically handle property damage claims in Florida? Personal injury lawyers usually avoid property damage claims due to recent tort reforms that eliminated attorney fee recovery for these cases. This change has made property damage claims less financially viable for attorneys who work on a contingency basis.
Q2. What's the difference between property damage and personal injury claims in Florida? Property damage claims focus on repair costs and diminished value of property, while personal injury claims cover medical expenses and pain and suffering. They follow separate legal processes, have different insurance procedures, and operate under distinct timelines.
Q3. Can I handle a property damage claim on my own? Yes, most standalone property damage claims can be resolved directly with insurance companies without legal representation. Proper documentation, including photos and detailed inventories, is crucial for successful negotiations.
The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute an attorney-client relationship.