Will Your Car Insurance Increase After Filing a Collision Claim After an Estero Accident?
Car insurance rates in Florida can skyrocket between 22% and 77% after an accident, leaving many drivers wondering exactly how much their insurance will go up after an accident. These increases vary significantly depending on your insurance provider, with companies like State Farm applying lower increases (around 22%) compared to others like Geico, which may raise rates by up to 77%.
Even accidents that aren't your fault can impact your premiums. Although Florida's no-fault insurance law requires drivers to use their own coverage regardless of who caused the accident, your rates might still increase. In fact, having three or more accidents within three years could lead to your policy being canceled, even if you weren't at fault in any of them.
This article reveals the real numbers behind insurance increases after collisions, examines how different insurers respond to claims, and explains the factors that determine your new premium. You'll also discover strategies to minimize rate hikes and learn about Florida Statute 626.9541, which prohibits insurers from raising premiums unless you're found significantly at fault.
What Happens to Your Insurance After a Collision Claim
Filing a collision claim often raises concerns about your future insurance costs. Let's examine what truly happens after you submit a claim and how it affects your premium.
When rate changes take effect
After filing a collision claim, your insurance rates won't change immediately. Typically, any potential rate increases take effect when your policy renews. Most insurers send new policy information and premium amounts approximately 30 days before your renewal date. This timing gives you an opportunity to evaluate your options before the new rates kick in.
If you're considering switching insurance providers after an accident, it's generally best to wait until your current policy is about to expire. This strategy helps you avoid potential early cancelation fees while giving you time to shop around for better rates.
How insurers assess your claim
When you report an accident, your insurance company launches an investigation process. A claim representative should contact you within a reasonable timeframe—sometimes within 15 days. During this assessment, the insurer may:
Take written or recorded statements from you
Contact other drivers and witnesses
Request documentation of injuries or expenses
Send an adjuster to inspect vehicle damage
The FBI reports that insurance fraud costs each family between $400 and $700 per year in increased premiums. This explains why insurers thoroughly investigate claims before making payment decisions.
Does insurance go up after accident claims?
The answer is: not necessarily, but usually yes. Car insurance rates increase by an average of 50% after an at-fault accident. However, several factors influence whether and how much your rates will rise:
First, the severity and cost of your claim matter significantly. Minor fender benders typically impact rates less than accidents resulting in totaled vehicles.
Second, fault determination is crucial. At-fault accidents generally cause larger premium increases than not-at-fault incidents, though some insurers raise rates slightly even when you're not responsible.
Third, your location plays a major role in rate increases. California has the most dramatic response, where an accident nearly doubles insurance rates, while Pennsylvania shows only a 23% increase.
Finally, most insurers consider accidents in your premium calculations for three to five years, with the largest increase occurring at your first renewal after the crash. Fortunately, these increases gradually decrease over time if you maintain a clean driving record.
Key Factors That Influence Rate Increases
Several key factors determine how much your premium will increase after filing a collision claim. Understanding these elements helps you better predict potential rate hikes.
Severity and cost of the accident
The financial impact of your accident directly influences your rate increase. Minor fender benders with negligible damage might not trigger substantial rate hikes, whereas accidents involving significant damage, injuries, or fatalities typically result in considerable premium increases. Insurance companies carefully evaluate repair costs, medical expenses, and overall claim payout when calculating new rates. Additionally, the more expensive your claim, the higher your subsequent premium is likely to be.
Who was at fault
Fault determination significantly affects your insurance outcome. Accidents you cause will almost always raise your insurance rate. Furthermore, in some states with comparative negligence rules, insurers assign fault percentages based on each party's contribution to the collision. Interestingly, even if you're not at fault, your insurer may still perceive you as a higher risk, especially if the other driver lacks adequate coverage. Nevertheless, some companies, like USAA, typically won't raise rates if you aren't responsible for an accident.
Claims history and driving record
Your claims trajectory matters enormously. Insurance companies examine several years of your driving history when calculating premiums. Multiple claims within a short period can signal higher risk, prompting more substantial increases. Moreover, the timing of claims is crucial—the more recent a claim, the more it affects your rates. Depending on your insurer, past claims may influence your premium for anywhere from three to ten years.
Location and ZIP code
Where you live fundamentally shapes your post-accident premium. Insurance companies analyze data specific to your ZIP code to assess risks like accident rates, theft frequency, and repair costs. Urban areas with heavy traffic and higher crime rates typically have premiums 50% higher than rural regions. Insurers evaluate numerous location-based factors including population density, traffic patterns, road conditions, natural disasters, crime rates, and even the number of uninsured motorists in your area.
Age and credit score
Personal characteristics substantially influence post-accident increases. Younger drivers typically face steeper rate hikes after an accident. Meanwhile, credit-based insurance scores impact premiums—studies show drivers with excellent credit file fewer claims than those with poor credit. Your driving record remains the most significant factor, potentially outweighing a less-than-stellar credit score.
Real Numbers: How Much Does Insurance Go Up After an Accident
After a collision claim, knowing exactly how much your insurance will go up helps you prepare financially. Let's examine the real numbers behind post-accident premium increases.
Average increase for at-fault accidents
When you cause an accident, your car insurance rates typically increase by an average of 50%. In dollar terms, this translates to about $80 more per month ($960 annually) for full coverage. According to recent analyzes, a 35-year-old driver with good credit could see their premium rise by approximately 45% after an at-fault accident. Consequently, understanding these numbers helps you budget for potential increases.
Rate hikes by insurance provider
Insurance companies vary dramatically in how they price policies after accidents:
State Farm shows the smallest increase at just 15-18%
Erie and Auto-Owners typically raise rates by 29-35%
Progressive increases premiums by about 50%
Geico implements some of the largest hikes at 69-72%[131]
Remarkably, the average annual premium from State Farm after an at-fault accident is $1,953, making it the most affordable option among major insurers.
How long do increases last?
Typically, accidents affect your insurance rates for three to five years. Indeed, the largest premium jump occurs at your first renewal following the crash. Thereafter, the surcharge gradually decreases—about 47% higher than normal after two years, dropping to just 2% higher after four years.
Does not-at-fault accident affect insurance?
Even when you're not at fault, your premium might increase slightly. According to industry experts, not-at-fault accidents usually raise rates by about 10% or less. Notwithstanding, some states (including Oklahoma and California) prohibit insurers from increasing rates for not-at-fault accidents.
I rear-ended someone—how much will my insurance go up?
Since rear-end collisions are almost always considered your fault, expect a substantial increase. For this specific scenario, your premium could jump by approximately 45%. Accordingly, a previously clean driving record might see your full coverage costs rise by nearly $1,108 annually after such an incident.
What You Can Do If Your Rates Go Up
When your insurance premium increases after an accident, you're not powerless. There are several effective strategies to manage or even prevent rate hikes.
Requesting explanation from your insurer
The best first step is simply asking your insurance representative how an accident will impact your rates. If you've enrolled in an accident forgiveness program before your collision, you might be eligible to have the surcharge waived entirely. Most programs allow you to waive the first at-fault accident within a set timeframe, typically three to five years. In addition to this, review your claim situation with your agent to determine the most advantageous route for your circumstances.
Providing proof of no fault
In states with no-fault insurance like Michigan, your rates will likely increase if you were at-fault but might still rise even if you weren't responsible. To contest this, provide comprehensive documentation proving you weren't at fault. Unfortunately, without specific prohibitions against it, your insurance company can increase your premium for any reason—or no reason at all. Yet, demonstrating your innocence might help minimize increases in some cases.
Shopping for better rates
Comparing quotes from different insurers before your policy renews helps ensure you're getting the best rate after an accident. In 2020, the average yearly rate increase after an at-fault collision claim was $658, potentially adding up to over $2,000 across three years. Given that, shopping around becomes crucial—the company that was cheapest before your accident might not remain so afterward.
How to avoid insurance increase after accident
Several preventive measures can help:
Enroll in accident forgiveness programs—Progressive offers forgiveness for claims under $500 in most states
Complete a defensive driving course to demonstrate commitment to safe driving
Ask about available discounts including safe driver deals and loyalty rewards
Consider a higher deductible to lower your monthly premium
Maintain a good credit score, as many insurers use this to determine rates
Remember to report accidents promptly—delaying might result in claim complications or coverage denial.
Conclusion
What to Remember About Insurance Claims and Rate Increases
Navigating car insurance after an accident certainly feels overwhelming. Throughout this article, we've examined the real numbers behind rate increases, which range from 22% to a staggering 77% depending on your insurer and circumstances. Above all, understanding that different insurance companies respond differently to claims helps you make informed decisions about your coverage.
Therefore, if you've recently been in an accident, remember that your rates won't change until your policy renewal date. This gives you approximately 30 days to explore alternatives if your premium increases significantly. Additionally, keeping detailed records of your accident can prove invaluable, especially when proving you weren't at fault.
For most drivers, rate increases last between three and five years, gradually decreasing if you maintain a clean driving record afterward. Though this might seem discouraging, several strategies can help minimize these increases. Accident forgiveness programs, defensive driving courses, and simply shopping around can all lead to substantial savings.
Your location and personal factors like age and credit score play significant roles in determining post-accident premiums. Consequently, improving these elements where possible can help offset potential increases.
If you have been injured in a car accident and need an attorney, call our Fort Myers, Cape Coral, Estero, Bonita Springs, and Naples Auto Accident Lawyers at Pittman Law Firm, P.L. today for a free consultation.
Finally, while insurance increases after an accident might be inevitable, they don't have to be permanent or devastating to your finances. Armed with the knowledge from this article, you can make better choices about when to file claims, which insurance provider to choose, and how to protect yourself financially after an accident.
FAQs
Q1. How much will my car insurance increase after filing a collision claim? On average, car insurance rates increase by about 50% after an at-fault accident. This translates to roughly $80 more per month or $960 annually for full coverage. However, the exact increase varies significantly depending on factors like your insurance provider, location, and the severity of the accident.
Q2. How long do insurance rate increases last after an accident? Typically, accidents affect your insurance rates for three to five years. The largest premium increase usually occurs at your first policy renewal following the crash. After that, the surcharge gradually decreases each year, assuming you maintain a clean driving record.
Q3. Will my insurance go up if I'm not at fault in an accident? Even if you're not at fault, your premium might increase slightly, usually by about 10% or less. However, some states prohibit insurers from raising rates for not-at-fault accidents. It's best to check with your insurance provider or state regulations for specific policies.
Q4. What can I do to minimize insurance rate increases after an accident? To minimize rate increases, consider enrolling in accident forgiveness programs, completing a defensive driving course, asking about available discounts, or increasing your deductible. Shopping around for quotes from different insurers before your policy renews can also help you find better rates after an accident.
Q5. Do all insurance companies raise rates the same amount after an accident? No, insurance companies vary dramatically in how they adjust premiums after accidents. For example, State Farm typically shows the smallest increase at 15-18%, while companies like Geico may raise rates by up to 69-72%. It's important to compare quotes from multiple insurers to find the best post-accident rates.
The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute an attorney-client relationship.